netcurmudgeon (netcurmudgeon) wrote,

  • Mood:
  • Music:


This week's Network World asks "Has the Office romance cooled?"

Of course it has. What is there in Office 2007 that's really new? I mean, new in a way that will actually help me write a better business letter?. In 1987 I was writing letters. In 1997 I was writing letters. In 2007 I'm still writing letters. You know what the big difference is over twenty years? In 1987 I was writing practice letters in my high school typing class, and for the past fourteen years I've been doing it for real. The format hasn't changed. The language hasn't changed. Not much has changed at all -- except that in '90s we had fax numbers and email addresses on our letterhead and now we have mobile numbers, web URLs and email addresses. Today, the fax is slowly going the way of the electric typewriter and the eight-track tape. But what about the tools? What about Word?

In 1987 I was using the Leading Edge Word Processor (LEWP). Most of the business world was using Word Perfect. There was XYwrite, IBM Writing Assistant and this upstart MS Word (for DOS) along with Lotus AmiPro and a slew of others. We all had pagination, spell checking, soft-tabs, underlining, italics, footnotes ... a laundry list of features. The average user probably only used 25% of them.

By 1993 two genuine revolutions had transpired and our writing tools really did advance -- WYSIWYG and proportionally-spaced fonts. In 1995 Windows users got access to TrueType fonts -- not so much of a revolution as an evolution -- they enabled anyone to create eye-bending typographic effects in Word or to have a 'dingasm' with all of the nifty stuff in Wingdings.

By our next dacadal way-point -- 1997 -- those revolutions were all old news. No one still used dot-matrix printers except offices and POS systems where they were printing multiple copies on NCR paper. My Panasonic KXP-1091i was gathering dust, and even my work-horse HP DeskJet 500 was out to pasture in favor of a LaserJet 6MP. The average user of MS Office 95 or Office 97 was using roughly 10% of the features available to them.

Now it's 2007 and Network World is wondering if the fire has gone out of the relationship. Um, yeah. While there will always be folks who want to get a new car every two to three years, a growing number of us denizens in the reality-based world look at a car with 100,000 miles on it and think now I'm starting to get my money's worth out of this thing. The same holds true for software. Office 4.3 (1993), Office 95, Office 97, Office 2000, Office XP, Office 2003 and now Office 2007. For someone who is just trying to write a letter or run a ledger, there really isn't much new here -- except for the licensing plan (eight flavors of Office 2007 to choose from!) and the bill.

This fall the House of Hum is reluctantly giving up Office 97 and moving to Office 2003 because -- and only because -- Microsoft's translator for the Office 2007 file formats is only available for Office 2003, and people are starting to lob .DOCX files over our virtual transom. We've had ten good years with Office 97 -- and part of that goodness was stability. Stability which meant that the tool receded into the background and we could concentrate on just getting our work done. Like most users, we probably only ever used 10% of the features in Word and Excel (though ashacat may now be pushing 20% with Excel's statistical analysis features), and 5% of PowerPoint and Access. Which, begs the next question.

Is the 5-7% of the Office 2007 feature set that our users are going to use worth the price tag and the disruption? Oh, and a second (rhetorical) question: given that the average corporate user has only basic mastery over things like shared folders and email attachments, do the geeks in Redmond really think that the vision-made-flesh in Office 2007 is something that mere mortals can follow? Maybe I'm showing my age and my mind is ossifying. You tell me. Is there something really compelling about Office 2007, or am I right in thinking that most of us would rather stop 'upgrading' and just get down to business?
Tags: geeking, microsoft, office 2007

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.